Top Stories

Mamdani unveils plan to close Rikers Island jail by 2032

Mamdani unveils plan to close Rikers Island by 2032 with four replacement jails, ending years of delays and changing how New York handles pre-trial detention

avatar-icon

News Desk

The News Desk provides timely and factual coverage of national and international events, with an emphasis on accuracy and clarity.

Mamdani unveils plan to close Rikers Island jail by 2032

The Rikers Island Prison complex (foreground) is seen from an airplane in the Queens borough of New York City, New York, U.S., April 2, 2017.

Reuters/File

New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani unveiled a plan on Friday to close the Rikers Island jail complex by 2032, after years of delays, BBC reported.

The proposal includes four replacement facilities and a significant reduction in the number of people held in the city's detention system.

Why is Mamdani closing Rikers Island?

Mamdani says Rikers Island's failing infrastructure is a compelling reason to close it, and that the city has a moral obligation to replace the existing system. The complex has faced decades of criticism over violence, staffing shortages and inmate deaths, including nine this year.

Mamdani made the case in an 88-page report released alongside the announcement. Rikers sits on a 413-acre (167-hectare) island between Queens and the Bronx, and the closure effort has gained urgency amid continuing concerns over conditions and inadequate staffing.

The controversy has also drawn federal intervention. Last year, a federal judge removed oversight of Rikers from the city and appointed an independent official to make decisions concerning the facility.

How many people are held at Rikers Island?

The complex currently holds more than 6,500 people on an average day. Mamdani's proposal aims to bring that population down to about 4,100, a target that has drawn opposition from the city's correction officers' union. The plan would also change how New York handles pre-trial detention.

The Correction Officers' Benevolent Association said imposing a fixed limit on jail capacity was irresponsible. It argued the cap could compromise public safety by forcing authorities to release people facing violent felony charges.

Dana Kaplan, whom Mamdani appointed to oversee the closure process, rejected the criticism. She argued that reducing the number of people held in detention was achievable and should be a central part of the city's long-term planning.

Kaplan told the BBC that the latest proposal represented an opportunity to rethink the city's approach to incarceration rather than simply replace an ageing facility. She described the initiative as a chance to establish a different detention model and reconsider how people should be held in custody.

When will Rikers Island close, and what will replace it?

The city first committed to shutting Rikers in 2019, with an initial target of 2027. However, implementation has repeatedly stalled, partly because of difficulties finding suitable locations for replacement jails. Mamdani blamed delays under former Mayor Eric Adams' administration and the COVID-19 pandemic for setbacks in meeting the original timetable.

Under the latest proposal, Brooklyn would receive a new jail by 2029, followed by facilities in the Bronx and Queens by 2031. A fourth facility in Manhattan is scheduled to open by 2032.

The mayor's office says the smaller jails will offer better living conditions, including access to natural light, fresh air and cleaner spaces. Their locations are also expected to make visits easier for families, many of whom face lengthy journeys to reach the isolated Rikers complex.

The revised closure schedule will require approval from the New York City Council, whose leadership has signaled support for the proposal.

Comments

See what people are discussing