US lawyer Clive Smith slams Pakistan delays in Aafia Siddiqui case

The Islamabad High Court heard sharp criticism on Monday from Clive Smith, the U.S.-based lawyer representing Dr. Aafia Siddiqui, over delays and inefficiencies in Pakistan’s efforts to secure her release and repatriation.

Smith, speaking via video link, said a Pakistani delegation sent to the U.S. for an eight-day mission arrived five days late and accomplished little during their visit.

Dr. Siddiqui, a Pakistani neuroscientist, is serving an 86-year sentence in the U.S. after being convicted in 2010 for attempting to attack U.S. soldiers in Afghanistan. Her case has sparked significant controversy, with many in Pakistan calling her a victim of injustice and advocating for her release.

The delegation, which included Senator Bushra Anjum Butt and Senator Talha, has completed its scheduled stay in the U.S. According to Smith, the Pakistani ambassador did not arrange any meetings related to the case.

Presiding over the case, Justice Sardar Ejaz Ishaq Khan expressed frustration at the government and Foreign Ministry for their handling of the case. He questioned the delegation’s performance and directed the Foreign Ministry to submit a comprehensive report detailing the reasons for the delays and lack of progress.

Senator Talha said he plans to present a resolution in parliament regarding Siddiqui’s case.

The Foreign Ministry’s representative informed the court that Dr. Fauzia Siddiqui, Aafia’s sister, had her visa application initially rejected. However, efforts are ongoing to secure approval, the representative said.

The court ordered the Secretary of Foreign Affairs to ensure the issuance of a B visa to Dr. Fauzia, who has been campaigning for her sister’s release.

Dr. Fauzia appeared in court alongside her lawyer, Imran Shafiq. She said she had written to top officials, including the president, prime minister, army chief, and spy chief, about her sister’s repatriation.

She also revealed that letters sent to the army chief and ISI chief were returned, despite acknowledgment of receipt. Dr. Fauzia presented the returned letters, with signatures confirming receipt, as evidence in court.

The court adjourned the hearing until next Friday.