Sports

Cricket Australia establishes independent forum to revisit 2018 ball-tampering scandal

The move comes after former Australia opener Usman Khawaja made fresh allegations in his recently published autobiography, Sabr, reigniting debate surrounding the infamous sandpaper scandal

avatar-icon

Sports Desk

The Sports Desk is the editorial team responsible for covering the latest news, updates, and analysis from the world of sports. Our team of experienced writers and journalists bring you in-depth coverage of local and international sports events, player profiles, and expert opinions.

Cricket Australia establishes independent forum to revisit 2018 ball-tampering scandal

Australia captain Pat Cummins strongly rejected Khawaja's allegations last Friday, describing them as "100% wrong" and "utter nonsense" during a 68-minute press conference.

Cricket Australia

Cricket Australia (CA) has announced to establish an independent forum where players and staff involved in the 2018 ball-tampering scandal can share their accounts of the controversial incident in South Africa.

CA interim chair David Boon and chief executive Todd Greenberg confirmed the decision at Bellerive Oval ahead of the third ODI between Australia and England on Wednesday, following an emergency board meeting held on Tuesday evening.

The move comes after former Australia opener Usman Khawaja made fresh allegations in his recently published autobiography, Sabr, reigniting debate surrounding the infamous sandpaper scandal.

Why has Cricket Australia decided to establish the forum?

Khawaja's book included claims that sandpaper had also been used during the preceding Test against South Africa in Port Elizabeth. He suggested that knowledge of the practice extended beyond the three players who were sanctioned and questioned why he had not been interviewed during CA's original investigation, despite sitting alongside Cameron Bancroft in the dressing room.

Former Australia vice-captain David Warner subsequently expressed support for Khawaja's account on social media.

Greenberg acknowledged the damage caused by the renewed controversy, saying: "The game is genuinely hurting at the moment. It's not good for anyone. We need to find a path through, and we need some time to heal."

He also revealed that only eight of the 11 players who featured in the Cape Town Test were interviewed during the original investigation. However, CA will not reopen that inquiry or release its findings because of confidentiality considerations.

How will the independent process work?

The proposed forum will provide an opportunity for anyone involved in the events to share their recollections voluntarily in a confidential environment.

CA intends to appoint an independent figure, potentially a King's Counsel or former judge, in the coming days. The terms of reference will also be established, while the board will subsequently determine whether any information from the process can be made public.

Boon stressed that the initiative was intended to help Australian cricket move forward rather than revisit disciplinary decisions.

"After careful discussion, we agreed to establish a forum that will allow players and staff involved in the events of South Africa in 2018 to share their experiences and their perspectives," Boon said.

He added: "This forum is not about re-litigating the past at all. It's about creating an opportunity for those who wish to be heard to tell their stories in a respectful, safe environment, and for our sport to listen."

Boon also described the prolonged controversy as a distraction, saying Australian cricket needed a circuit breaker after almost a decade of debate.

Greenberg, who confirmed regular communication with Khawaja and Warner, reiterated that participation would be entirely voluntary.

"It's not a re-investigation. It's not designed to re-prosecute or to sanction," he said.

He acknowledged that the exercise might not settle every disagreement, adding: "Someone's version of events will contradict someone else's version of events. So looking for the perfect truth doesn't exist, and we're not chasing that."

The process is not expected to conclude before Australia's first Test against New Zealand.

How have Khawaja and Warner responded?

Khawaja welcomed the opportunity to speak but questioned whether the initiative would deliver the transparency the public wanted.

"I have always wanted a safe space to chat… I also have some questions about Cricket Australia because the public want to know what happened there," he told Kayo Sports.

He also raised concerns about the board controlling what information eventually becomes public.

"Are we just going in a circle here? That's the thing I'm not sure about."

Khawaja maintained that additional punishments were unnecessary, a position shared by Warner.

"We put our hands up, we accepted what Cricket Australia handed out to us. It's not about penalties. It's about transparency and accountability, which Todd's acknowledged, on CA's behalf, about the culture at the time with the players and CA," Warner said.

Why does the controversy remain divisive?

Australia captain Pat Cummins strongly rejected Khawaja's allegations last Friday, describing them as "100% wrong" and "utter nonsense" during a 68-minute press conference. Fast bowler Mitchell Starc had also denied having any knowledge of sandpaper use.

Greenberg defended the consistency of the bowlers' accounts, saying Cummins had maintained the same position since the Cape Town Test in 2018.

However, former Australia seamer Chadd Sayers, who was part of the touring squad and made his Test debut in the Johannesburg Test immediately after the scandal, supported Khawaja's claims.

Sayers said he knew about the sandpaper being used in Port Elizabeth and was responsible for carrying it off the field after Bancroft had used it. He also believed the entire squad knew what was happening.

Furthermore, Sayers backed Khawaja's account of a 70-minute meeting in the Cape Town dressing room, where players allegedly discussed accepting collective responsibility for the incident.

What has Bancroft revealed about the scandal?

The controversy intensified further on Wednesday after Cameron Bancroft broke his silence, claiming the entire Australian team knew about the ball-tampering plan.

In an extensive article published in The West Australian, the former opener admitted he had never been completely honest during the initial investigation and had effectively "took the bullet for everybody".

Bancroft said Khawaja's autobiography prompted him to speak out, adding: "I have key recollections which affirm what he is saying".

He alleged that David Warner managed the ball-tampering operation before Bancroft took over in Port Elizabeth, with the knowledge of several teammates and coaching staff members.

The 33-year-old claimed he regularly discussed the ball's movement with fast bowlers Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc and Josh Hazlewood, as well as Mitchell Marsh and wicketkeeper Tim Paine.

"All the bowlers gave me feedback if my work on the ball was working," he said.

He further alleged that bowling coach David Saker had instructed him to do more with the ball during the Cape Town Test, while claiming that former head coach Darren Lehmann was also aware of the plan.

Recalling the aftermath of his dismissal, Bancroft said reserve player Peter Handscomb was instructed to remove the sandpaper from him.

"In my opinion, if he [Lehmann] didn’t know he wouldn’t have said that and if it wasn’t clear enough before ... once again. WE ALL KNEW," he wrote.

Bancroft also described himself as the scapegoat for the incident, expressing regret over the initial press conference and the subsequent public denials by teammates.

He confirmed he would be willing to participate in Cricket Australia's newly announced independent forum.

Responding to Bancroft's latest revelations, Cricket Australia said it respected his decision to share his account and would consider his comments.

"We respect that Cameron Bancroft has told his story, and we will take time to consider his comments.

"We expect that there will be many dimensions to the events of 2018, which is why we have established the forum for individuals to give their version of events.

"We are finalising the terms of reference and will commence the process as soon as possible."

Comments

See what people are discussing