https://www.facebook.com/aamirsaeed.abbassi?mibextid=ZbWKwL
https://x.com/AmirSaeedAbbasi?t=wgV5MoIU6BswArSR0mVyRQ&s=08
https://www.instagram.com/aamirsaeedabbasi/
Top Stories

Federal court allows PHC to hear most Article 199 cases

The Federal Constitutional Court has modified its Nov. 5 stay order, letting the PHC hear most Article 199 cases except governor's rule and emergency matters.

avatar-icon

Aamir Abbasi

Editor, Islamabad

Aamir; a journalist with 15 years of experience, working in Newspaper, TV and Digital Media. Worked in Field, covered Big Legal Constitutional and Political Events in Pakistan since 2009 with Pakistan’s Top Media Organizations. Graduate of Quaid I Azam University Islamabad.

Federal court allows PHC to hear most Article 199 cases
The petition asks the FCC to allow the PHC to hear challenges to the federal government's measures.
Nukta

Pakistan's Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) on Monday modified its Nov. 5 stay order, allowing the Peshawar High Court (PHC) to hear most Article 199 cases. Restrictions remain on matters involving governor's rule, an emergency and Maintenance of Public Order (MPO) measures, after petitioners said the order had halted proceedings.

Which Article 199 cases can the PHC now hear?

The Peshawar High Court can now hear most petitions filed under Article 199 of the Constitution. The Federal Constitutional Court clarified that its stay order covers only cases concerning governor's rule and the imposition of an emergency. All other Article 199 petitions may proceed before the high court.

A two-member bench headed by Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan heard the matter, with Justice Amir Farooq also on the bench. Barrister Gohar Khan argued that the Nov. 5 order had affected proceedings at the PHC and effectively brought legal proceedings in several cases to a halt.

What did the judges say about Article 245 and the detainees?

Justice Amir Farooq observed that a straightforward reading of Article 245 could suggest proceedings under Article 199 could not be heard. He cautioned that such an interpretation could bring the entire judicial system to a standstill.

The court allowed the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Bar Council to become a party to the proceedings. The Advocate General of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa told the court that the provincial government had submitted its response in compliance with an earlier order. He said the law allows a person detained for more than three months to approach the relevant board.

Latif Khosa argued that proceedings on all petitions filed under Article 199 had effectively been suspended. Gohar said the admissibility of petitions before the PHC also needed to be determined. He told the court that several people were in custody and that Khyber Pakhtunkhwa did not have a relief board. He urged the court to decide the petitions at the earliest, adding that some detainees had been held in police lines. The court adjourned further proceedings for an indefinite period.

What did the KP government say about military deployment?

Separately, the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government submitted its response to the FCC's Nov. 5 order concerning the deployment of armed forces in the province. In its response, filed through the advocate general, the government maintained that continuous deployment throughout the province, without exception, remained indispensable to assist the civil administration.

It said there was currently no intention to withdraw the armed forces from any district or area or to end their deployment. The government added that the civil administration and law enforcement agencies required continued military assistance and a physical presence to protect human lives, government property and key state installations.

The FCC had sought details from the provincial government about the deployment, including which districts still required military assistance and where it was no longer necessary.

What did Gohar say after the hearing?

Speaking to the media after the hearing, Gohar said proceedings before the PHC would remain restricted only to cases concerning governor's rule and an emergency. He said the court had accepted the request to make the petitioners a party to the proceedings and clarified that other Article 199 cases could proceed before the high court.

Responding to a separate question about meetings involving people allegedly favored by Salman Akram Raja, Khosa said anyone possessing "moral courage" should resign. He added that those considered favorites were the people who frequently appeared in the media.

Comments

See what people are discussing