Pakistan Idol 2 vs Indian Idol 16: Time to raise the bar

Despite the strong fan support for Pakistan Idol Season 2, an honest reflection is essential to help the show evolve and truly showcase national talent. Constructive criticism identifies what works — and what needs work — turning a good show into a great one.

Elevate Production Quality

From sound and set design to lighting and editing, every technical detail deserves meticulous attention. The contrast with Indian Idol is clear: their clever use of behind-the-scenes (BTS) footage and interactive judge-contestant clips fuels engaging Instagram reels that keep the audience hooked.

Meanwhile, many viewers still struggle to find Pakistan Idol online. While Indian Idol’s judges connect with the audience through GoPro moments and casual selfies, our production still faces sound inconsistencies and uninspired graphics. The fix? Invest in innovation and polish across every frame.

Host and Judge synergy

Host Shafaat Ali’s delivery feels scripted and lacks flow, with judges Rahat Fateh Ali Khan, Zeb Bangash, Fawad Khan, and Bilal Maqsood. The show could draw inspiration from Indian Idol’s charismatic hosts — Aditya Narayan, Hussain Kuwajerwala, or Manish Paul — who master the art of timing, spontaneity, and connection.

A cohesive, energetic rapport between the host and judges can transform the show’s rhythm and viewer engagement.

Meaningful gestures matter

Awards like the Golden Mic or Platinum Mic should be more than decorative gimmicks. They symbolize recognition, not ratings. When sincere, these gestures honor true talent and reinforce the credibility of the competition.

Remembering our roots

Who was Pakistan’s very first Idol? Zamad Baig. Where is he now? What’s he doing? Inviting him back — as the inaugural winner — would pay tribute to the show’s legacy and remind viewers that Pakistan Idol celebrates not just voices, but journeys.

Amplify audition buzz and opportunities

Future seasons should spotlight auditions in Lahore, Karachi, Islamabad, and Hyderabad through dynamic social media campaigns. Encourage emerging talent and extend opportunities beyond the finale — from OST performances to collaborations with film and drama industry professionals.

Meaningful incentives and continued mentorship will not only keep contestants motivated but also sustain audience excitement for Pakistan Idol’s next chapter.

Constructive critique is the most loyal form of support. It’s time to polish, innovate, and engage — so Pakistan’s brightest voices can shine on a stage worthy of their talent.