Videos

New provinces debate exposes divisions within government

Kamran Khan said Pakistan's four-province system faces growing scrutiny over concentrated power and resources

avatar-icon

News Desk

The News Desk provides timely and factual coverage of national and international events, with an emphasis on accuracy and clarity.

- YouTube

The debate over creating new provinces in Pakistan is gaining political momentum, exposing divisions within the federal government and resistance from major political parties. While several ministers have openly backed the idea of new administrative units and a possible public referendum, the silence of the PML-N's top leadership and the PPP's outright opposition raise questions about whether the proposal has the political backing needed to move forward.

In the latest episode of On My Radar, Kamran Khan said Pakistan's long-standing four-province administrative structure was facing an unprecedented political challenge, as decision-makers increasingly recognized that the concentration of power and resources in a few hands had contributed to economic distress, poverty and unemployment.

The debate, initially sparked by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi's proposal for new provinces or administrative units, has since gained support from several senior government ministers. The discussion has also moved towards the possibility of holding a public referendum, with proponents arguing that any decision should reflect the people's wishes and be implemented in accordance with the Constitution and the law.

However, a key question remains whether this represents a unified government policy or merely the individual views of a few ministers. Despite their support for smaller provinces and administrative units, the PML-N's central leadership has yet to clarify its position.

Former prime minister Nawaz Sharif has remained silent on the issue, while Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif has made no public announcement supporting the creation of new provinces. Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz has also stayed away from the debate, despite Punjab's central role in determining whether the proposal can advance.

The demand for a separate South Punjab province has existed for years, and the PML-N has itself supported the idea in the past. Backing from the Punjab Assembly could provide a significant constitutional and political foundation for efforts to redraw the country's administrative map.

Without Punjab's support, however, making progress on the issue would be extremely difficult, particularly given the PPP's strong opposition to any division of Sindh. President Asif Ali Zardari, party chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari and other senior PPP leaders have openly rejected the proposal. The Sindh Assembly has also passed several resolutions opposing the creation of new provinces.

Speaking at the Karachi Press Club on Wednesday, Bilawal warned that any attempt to forcibly divide Sindh would lead to bloodshed on the streets of Karachi and Hyderabad, adding that the resulting tensions would not remain confined to a single city.

He also rejected the proposal for a referendum, arguing that referendums in Pakistan had historically been used for undemocratic purposes. He accused the government of seeking an unconstitutional route instead of following established constitutional procedures.

Bilawal further said the debate over provincial restructuring was being imposed on the country despite the matter having never been discussed in parliament or taken up by the federal cabinet.

Responding to Bilawal's remarks, Information Minister Attaullah Tarar explicitly backed the idea of a referendum, saying people had the right to decide whether they wanted additional provinces.

Pakistan's existing administrative structure is therefore facing growing scrutiny at the national level. Several government ministers are advocating new provinces, the defense minister has expressed hope for political consensus, and the information minister has endorsed a referendum. Yet, the country's major political players remain divided over how, or even whether, the proposal should move forward.

Ultimately, changing the four-province structure will require far more than political statements or calls for a referendum. It will depend on building consensus in parliament, provincial assemblies and across political parties. Punjab's position will be particularly decisive. If its political leadership and assembly support the proposal, the debate over new provinces could enter a more consequential phase.

The questions now are when Nawaz Sharif and Shehbaz Sharif will clarify the PML-N's position, whether the Punjab Assembly will support the creation of new provinces, and whether the PPP is prepared to show any flexibility on its opposition to dividing Sindh.

For now, the PPP's uncompromising stance and the PML-N's silence suggest that the prospect of creating new provinces remains distant, despite growing discussion within government circles.

Comments

See what people are discussing